Content courtesy of Ary Rosenbaum, Esq., of The Rosenbaum Law Firm P.C. Learn more at therosenbaumlawfirm.com.
When I look ahead to 2026, I can’t help but think of Rocky Balboa. Not the invincible Rocky from Rocky III strutting around in silk robes, but the older one, in the later films, the guy who knows every punch is going to hurt but still gets in the ring anyway. Because, like Rocky said about Apollo Creed, “Time takes everybody out. Time’s undefeated.” And for 401(k) plan sponsors, time, and the tidal wave of change coming with 2026, is going to be undefeated too. You can’t duck it, you can’t outlast it, and you can’t charm your way out of it with a slick plan document or a nice fiduciary policy. You’ve got to face it head-on, gloves up, ready to take some hits. The good news? You can still win this fight. But only if you know what’s coming, and how to prepare.
The SECURE 2.0 Hangover: Catch-Up Chaos and Operational Headaches
Let’s start with the biggest headline, the 2026 Roth catch-up rule. Congress, in all its wisdom, decided that beginning in 2026, any participant earning more than $145,000 in the prior year must have their catch-up contributions made as Roth, not pre-tax. On paper, that sounds simple. In practice, it’s a logistical nightmare. Payroll systems, recordkeepers, and plan sponsors will have to coordinate to ensure that deferrals above the regular limit are properly flagged, characterized, and deposited as after-tax Roth contributions. It’s not just flipping a switch, it’s rewriting payroll logic, testing integrations, revising plan documents, and retraining staff. The IRS gave us a one-year reprieve by delaying implementation to 2026, but that grace period is almost up. The problem is, too many sponsors treated that delay as a snooze button instead of an alarm clock. Now, the bell’s ringing. You’ll need to confirm your provider’s readiness, your payroll system’s capabilities, and your employees’ understanding of the change. And while you’re at it, make sure your plan’s written provisions line up with your operational reality. Nothing gets you tripped up faster in an audit than “we meant to do this” when your records show otherwise. Because when the IRS or DOL comes knocking, “we didn’t get around to it” is not a legal defense, it’s an invitation to penalties.
Fiduciary Fitness: The New Lawsuit Playbook
The plaintiff’s bar has discovered something: there’s blood in the water, and it’s coming from plan sponsors who got complacent. The lawsuits that dominated the last decade focused on excessive fees and poor investments. Those aren’t going away, but the next wave is even more granular, forfeiture mismanagement, missed deposits, late remittances, cybersecurity lapses, and Roth mischaracterizations. In other words, even if your investments are well-chosen and your recordkeeper fees are pristine, plaintiffs will find something new to poke at. They always do. Plan sponsors can’t just rely on their TPA or recordkeeper to “handle it.” You’ve got to document your fiduciary process, every decision, every review, every rationale. Minutes matter. Fee benchmarking matters. Documentation matters more than ever. As I always tell clients, if it’s not in writing, it didn’t happen. And if it didn’t happen, you’re in trouble.
Cybersecurity: The Silent Threat That Doesn’t Knock
Rocky didn’t lose to Clubber Lang because he wasn’t strong, he lost because he got comfortable. He stopped training like the hungry kid from Philly and started believing his own press. That’s how plan sponsors treat cybersecurity. They think it’s someone else’s problem, the recordkeeper, the payroll provider, the IT team. But under ERISA, you’re the fiduciary. The buck stops with you. In 2026, cybersecurity won’t just be a buzzword. It’ll be the new frontline for fiduciary risk. Regulators have made it clear: sponsors must ensure participant data and assets are secure, tested, and monitored. That means vendor due diligence, insurance coverage, staff training, and actual, verifiable controls. And when, not if, a breach happens, the question will be simple: Did you do enough to prevent it? In a world where AI-generated phishing emails can mimic your TPA’s exact language, the stakes couldn’t be higher. Cybersecurity isn’t a box to check, it’s a responsibility to prove.
Alternative Investments: The Allure and the Trap
You’ve probably seen the headlines about private equity and alternative assets finding their way into 401(k)s. It sounds innovative, right? Diversification, new opportunities, better returns. Until you realize that with every “innovation” comes complexity, illiquidity, opaque valuations, and fiduciary headaches. As the DOL slowly warms to alternatives in retirement plans, expect more providers to push them. But sponsors need to tread carefully. It’s not just about whether the investment looks good, it’s about whether it fits your participants’ needs, your plan’s structure, and your fiduciary comfort zone. The moment you add complexity, you add liability. And unless you’re ready to explain to a regulator or plaintiff’s lawyer how your process ensured suitability, it’s better to stay in your lane.
The Rising Tide of Compliance and Oversight
It’s not paranoia if the DOL really is watching. 2026 will bring heightened scrutiny, on reporting accuracy, fiduciary training, cybersecurity, and even late participant notices. The agencies have been hiring staff and sharpening their focus. Expect more letters, more questions, and fewer free passes. Small and mid-sized employers are especially vulnerable because they often assume their providers are handling compliance. But under ERISA, delegation isn’t absolution. Even if your recordkeeper or TPA handles day-to-day tasks, the sponsor remains responsible for oversight. Translation: trust, but verify.
The Payroll Problem No One Talks About
Payroll errors are the silent killer of plan compliance. Whether it’s incorrect eligibility tracking, wrong deferral percentages, or missed match contributions, payroll integration is where most plans fall apart. 2026 will magnify that. The Roth catch-up rule and SECURE 2.0’s expanded automatic enrollment and eligibility rules will stress-test every payroll system out there. You’ll need to audit your payroll interface, reconcile contribution timing, and test data flows regularly. One wrong file upload can turn into a correction nightmare. Think of it like Rocky’s training montage, repetition, discipline, and sweat. Every punch, every push-up, every reconciliation report matters.
The Cost of Doing Nothing
Here’s the uncomfortable truth: many plan sponsors will wait too long. They’ll assume their providers are on top of it. They’ll plan to “get to it after year-end.” Then 2026 arrives, and suddenly, they’re behind. By then, it’ll be like walking into the 15th round with no energy left. The rules will change, the expectations will rise, and those who didn’t train for it will get knocked down fast. But that’s when you find out what kind of sponsor you really are — because, as Rocky told his son, “It ain’t about how hard you hit. It’s about how hard you can get hit and keep moving forward.” That’s the mindset plan sponsors need now. You’re going to get hit — by regulations, by audits, by operational complexity. The key is not to avoid the punches but to take them, learn, and adapt.
Building Your 2026 Survival Plan
So, what should plan sponsors do right now?
Coordinate with your providers — Payroll, recordkeeper, and TPA alignment is everything. Make sure everyone knows their role for Roth catch-ups, auto-enrollment, and contribution limits.
Document everything — Every decision, every benchmark, every plan amendment. Paper trails are your best defense.
Audit your data — Eligibility, deferrals, and matches. Fix errors before regulators find them.
Train your fiduciary committee — Make sure everyone understands what’s changing and why.
Update your cybersecurity protocols — Verify vendor protections, require audits, and get insurance coverage.
Revisit your investment menu — Especially if someone pitches you on alternatives. Know what you’re signing up for.
Communicate with participants — Clarity builds trust. Don’t let employees learn about changes from a newsletter before hearing from you.
This isn’t just about compliance, it’s about leadership. Plan sponsors set the tone for the entire benefit culture of an organization. If you’re proactive, transparent, and disciplined, participants notice.
Going the Distance
The truth is, 2026 isn’t going to be easy. It’s going to test patience, systems, and stamina. But that’s what separates the real fiduciaries from the ones who just sign the 5500. Like Rocky said, time’s undefeated. But the greats don’t fight to beat time, they fight to make every round count. They keep getting up. They keep swinging. For plan sponsors, that means embracing change, mastering the details, and preparing for what’s next before it lands. Because there’s no bell you can hide behind, no referee to save you. The punches are coming. But if you’ve done your training, if you’ve checked your plan, your process, and your purpose, you’ll still be standing when the final bell rings. And that’s the real win.
DISCLAIMER: Because of the generality of this update, the information provided herein may not be applicable in all situations and should not be acted upon without specific legal advice based on particular situations. Attorney Advertising.
Copyright, 2025 The Rosenbaum Law Firm P.C. All rights reserved. Prior results do not guarantee similar outcome.
The Rosenbaum Law Firm P.C., 734 Franklin Avenue, Suite 302, Garden City, New York 11530, (516) 594-1557, www.therosenbaumlawfirm.com
This article is for educational and informational purposes only and does not constitute investment, tax, or legal advice, nor a recommendation to buy or sell any security or to adopt any investment strategy. All investing involves risk, including the possible loss of principal, and past performance is not a guarantee of future results. Please consult a qualified professional regarding your individual circumstances before making any financial decisions.